US Cable TV News – A Critique May 1, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Media, TV News.Tags: America, CNN, DailyShow, Fox, FoxNews, Jon Stewart, JonStewart, MSNBC, News
add a comment
Ever since the months leading up to the presidential elections last year I have been paying close attention to the American media. At first it was to gage what the sentiments for each candidate were at home. I knew for a fact that the world view was the Obama was the best candidate, since the Republican ticket, internationally, was tarnished by the Bush era, yet I was wanting to find out what the “average Joe (the plumber?)” was thinking across in actual America.
I already new generally what to expect from the US media landscape. In the right corner was Fox News, infamous for its “Fair and Balanced” slogan, which after only watching five minutes of it when on holiday knew was baloney. Next on the left was MSNBC on the left, and somewhere floating in between them was CNN. Herein begins the problem. So immediately you know, before you turn on the news channel, what view you will get. However when coming to watch news coverage I did not realise that I was not stumbling upon news, I was stumbling upon hour after hour of opinion. ]
The primetime news schedule in the USA is dominated by personalities, such as on Fox Bill O’Reilly, Sean Hannity and Glenn Beck; on MSNBC you have Keith Olbermann and Chris Matthews and CNN with Campbell Brown, Lou Dobbs and Larry King.
Each anchor has their own show style and different way of presenting. However the vast majority are not covering news as such. They mention a news story, and then consequently push their opinion on the viewer. There is nothing wrong with opinion, however is there too much of it now on US cable news.
A quick look a the prime time schedule of most news networks shows that they are saturated with these shows, almost masquerading as news. On the right at 8pm, you have ratings winner Bill O’Reilly on Fox News with the “No Spin Zone” on the O’Reilly Factor. (He’s very modest about his ratings, you never ever hear him refer to them, ever….) On the left Keith Olvermann with Countdown on MSNBC. They both present basically opnion spun towards their target audience. So basically, most of the time, you have MSNBC getting into bed the the democrats and Obama, whereas on the other side Fox is panning the hell out of government, the president and over analysing every single error seemingly made. They had eight years where “their side” was in power, and now, they do not like it as much it seems.
However, the problem I find is that aside from these opinion shows, there are actual news shows during the day. These shows are meant to be news, however you often see the anchor get angry, emotive and cast their own opinions on things. Take this clip here from Fox’s Shep Smith. Too involved in the coverage?
It seems that anchors are not more important than the coverage itself, and networks are becoming more and more partisan. Instances now like Glenn Beck on Fox News are becoming big hits in the news channel schedule. At 5pm on a weekday I would want to turn on the TV to see what had been happening in the world, not some “comedian” cast their views on the news. See this here. This is NEWS, not theatre.
It is the same over on MSNBC too, the left are equally as bad. Olberman has segments such as “Worst Person in the World” Most of the time these are anchors on Fox News. Then in return Fox News hurl abuse back at MSNBC. It is like watching two 6 year olds slinging mud at each other. It is ridiculous.
O’Reilly had Jon Stewart on his show a few years back, and O’Reilly said it was worrying that many young people use The Daily Show as their first point of call for news material in America. Are you surprised anymore? There seems to be nowhere in America to get news in a conventional way without it passing through an agenda sodden filter or being displayed as if it were a comedy show. At least The Daily Show portrays itself as a comedy show, unlike the news networks which are becoming all too much the same.
I can longer can see what keeps me sane April 29, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Internet, Media News.Tags: Comedy Central, ComedyCentral, Daily Show, DailyShow, Google, Internet, Jon Stewart, JonStewart, Streaming
add a comment
A horrifying event yesterday occurred. Something I have been dreading for a while. The thing which keeps me sane in this world of twenty-four hour news, newspaper sensationalism and economic meltdown, has been barred from Europe it seems. 
The thing which keeps me sane in this world is The Daily Show with Jon Stewart. The Comedy Central “faux-news” (however recently proving to sometimes being more reliable than actual news and business networks in America), has allowed, ever since I remember wanting to watch it, viewers outside the USA to watch the daily tirade of humour at the sometimes ridiculous world of journalism and politics. Yesterday, sometime between the morning and evening European time, the website seemingly blocked all viewing outside the US. Although you can still watch most of the show on the website, they are not full episode and small parts are missing.This smacks of something awful, and there is only one reason why, money.
The Daily Show is shown on Comedy Central, which in turn is owned by MTV Networks, part of the huge media conglomerate Viacom. Indeed, this conglomerate has a history of chasing unpaid rights from sites such as YouTube seen here. So the chances are that head-honchos are worried that they are making no money from this stream when outside the US.
If they are going to make it conventionally unavailable on their official website, it is only going to force people “underground” in the ways to get their fix of Jon Stewart. Surely there are ways round this, such as targeted regional advertising on the website to help pay for this. It’s not difficult. I believe a company called Google could help…however then I remember, Viacom are at war with them.
Whipping up a storm again April 28, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Newspapers.Tags: DailyExpress, DailyMail, Fear, Flu, FrontPages, Swine, SwineFlu
1 comment so far

Tuesday morning’s Express looks like this:

Seemingly whipping us up into a frenzy of panic with the manic red underlining of “IS”. “KILLER FLU” – yes, but so far only in Mexico. We have still to see a case away from Mexico where this strain is a killer. There are indeed only 2 confirmed cases at the moment.
All I can see this headline as being for is to scare the population into buying this title.
Time to give credit where credit is due, The Daily Mail so far have avoiding hitting the big panic button which all tabloid editors must have in their offices. 
Indeed, you could view their headline as being very sensible and factual and NOT scaremongering. There is a battle to contain it and the insistence on the face the Britain is prepared, is good. Indeed the best thing about the Mail is that they have avoided the Express’ KILLER method.
I also do like how the Express are trying to flog cheap holidays at the moment! Excellent advertising timing!
In response to the earlier article… April 27, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Uncategorized.add a comment
Perfect example of what I mentioned in my previous article.
Swine flu and the proliferation of fear April 27, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Internet, Newspapers.Tags: DailyExpress, DailyMail, Fear, Flu, Fox, FoxNews, FrontPages, Swine, SwineFlu
add a comment
Before I start this blog entry I would just like to state that I am not overlooking the possible consequences that the world is posed by this virus, and that I do believe it is truly a threat. This article deals with how
the informaton is propagated in the media.
One thing I noticed this weekend was the swift action of the media to this story and in particular the “p” word “pandemic. No doubting for a second that a new virus is serious news, and there is no questioning that it demands headline news. We all do need to know the facts and the information quickly, so we as the public are aware and if needed, take preventative measures.
But can the media be accused of scaremongering this virus already. We are only just gaining knowledge of it’s genetics and how people react to it, therefore there are wide range of projections as it’s mortality rate. As this is being written the estimated death toll is at around one hundred people, of which twenty have been confirmed to definitely be of the A/H1N1 strain, this taken from around 1,600 people in Mexico City who are believed to have contracted the virus. Again, these are unconfirmed cases and are suspect only.
What striked me, hidden down the story in a Guardian article today was this paragraph
Health officials [in Mexico City] believe that tens of thousands, and possibly more, have been infected but have since recovered.

This is the first time that I have seen this mentioned anywhere in the media. If this is the case, then maybe the virus could not be as dangerous as being portrayed in much of the media.
Sure, the “worst case scenario” should definitely be reported, but at the same time, the “best case scenario” should also be given more prominence. If tens of thousands in Mexico City have already has this strain before it was picked on the radar, and have recovered, then we are looking at something more like a regular strain of flu. The fact also that cases in the USA are responding well to anti-viral drugs such as Tamflu, is a good indicator.
However, what could be seen as scaremongering is happening on several high profile websites and news outlets.

As can be seen in the images from The Daily Express, FoxNews.com and The Daily Mail Online the main point is on seemingly scaring the reader into believing that the worse is to come. Particularly as the seen in the express where they claim 120 million could die. I have yet to see that sort of projection anywhere.
Indeed as I said earlier, there is no doubt a huge threat my this new influenza strain, however, we need do not need scaremongering. The public need all the facts, unfiltered and unaltered with and an analysis which shows the “best case scenario” as well as the worst, to prevent this from becoming a media instigated scare-fest.

Hello world! April 20, 2009
Posted by aiderushton in Uncategorized.1 comment so far
Welcome to WordPress.com. This is your first post. Edit or delete it and start blogging!